After everybody knowing they were going to do it, the New York Islanders recently revealed their new, Brooklyn-inspired third jerseys.
For a team with a long history of some pretty awful third jerseys and questionable uniform-related decisions all around (the swirly, wave like bottoms of the notorious Fisherman jerseys comes to mind), fans of the team were pretty nervous to see what concoction they would come up with this time. Moving to Brooklyn from Nassau County, it was clear that the team was going to go black and white, to match their arena mates, the Brooklyn Nets.
The results are…pretty good.
The Islanders have come up with something simple yet pleasing to the eye. Looking at these unis, it is clear that they will look pretty good on the ice, contrasting the white of the team the ice, and of the team that they will be playing against.
Here are some of my thoughts on the new third jerseys:
The “NY” logo, started last year for their outdoor game, is a nice, simple design that really stands out on the jersey. It is not too radically different from their classic logo, yet works very well as something different.
The four orange stripes on the stick portion of the “Y” is a great element. It offers the slightest amount of pop in colour, and of course is a nod to the teams four Stanley Cup wins.
I love the thin striping on the sleeves, matched by the same ones on the socks. It looks classy. Again, related to the four Cups.
Thankfully, there is a stripe at the waist. Every team that has gone away from the bottom stripe looks awful, and makes their unis looks like pajamas.
The name and numbers font is clean, uncluttered, and easy to see.
I like the simple white stripe around the wrist, as well. It offers a nice contrast, and again, avoids the PJ look.
The new BKLYN wordmark that will be worn on the helmets looks really good. It is dangerous to change things up, but the designers have done a good job in blending the classic with the new. Again, the four orange stripes make an appearance.
On the pants, there is a pretty large NY on the left thigh. I have a read a couple of reviews that don’t like this element at all, but I don’t mind it. I feel it breaks up the black nicely, providing a nice visual contrast. Of course, we know what team it is, since the jersey logo isn’t too far away, but I think it adds a certain amount of flash to the uniform.
The white ring that goes almost all the way around the collar also provides that nice contrast. It is simple, and not gimmicky. It works for me.
Overall, I would say that this is a big jersey win for the Islanders. After so many debatable ones, this black-and-white comes across as a winner. They will wear the new threads a dozen times in the upcoming season, and for the first time in a while, it will not be an eyesore to see them on the ice. They are clean, and have a level of sophistication, which makes them one of the better thirds in the entire league.
John Spano was supposed to save the New York Islanders. A team mired in a ton of poor decisions, from the players on the ice to the management choices at the top, they had quickly turned from legendary dynasty at the start of the 80’s to the laughingstock of the NHL. And rightfully so.
They even messed with tradition, trading out the iconic Islanders logo for the new fisherman jersey in the mid-90’s, leaving fans crying out for changes all the way through the organization.
Spano, a business man from Dallas, stepped up and was going to buy the team, keep them on Long Island, and return them to the form of their glory days.
But there was a problem.
He had no money.
As always, ESPN manages to tell a really interesting story here in their 30 for 30 series. Big Shot lets us know how a man could possibly buy a professional sports franchise without any capital, and in the meantime, lets us behind the scenes into the minds of the long-suffering Islander fans, and their further dashed hopes of organizational stability.
Directed by Entourage alum and Islander die-hard fan Kevin Connolly, they story in Big Shot is solid. He goes back to tell the tales of the making of the team, and their rapid and sad fall from grace. The buffoonery of the 90’s is brought out with candid interviews with key players, like Mad Mike Millbury, and Spano himself. It weaves an interesting story, of how he actually did manage to gain control of the team, based on lies and promised bank loans, lame excuses, and really, only a $17,000 deposit on the team. It tells us the story about how it really is more important to know rich and important people than it is to be a rich and important person yourself.
This series is so consistent in its level of storytelling. A fan of the New York Islanders myself, the subject area is definitely of interest, even if this is not the best 30 for 30 out there. One of the major flaws is Connolly himself. While he proves adept at putting together a documentary, telling the story, and directing it, his major flaw was using himself as a narrator. Not that he was terrible, and his personal connection to the Isles definitely added to the story, but his voice just doesn’t sound…right for the part. Although this is only a superficial complaint, it really did take a little bit away from the story, hearing him jump in with his stories. It was hard not to picture Eric chiding Vince on screwing up another movie role on Entourage.
Besides that, you get what you expect here: another great behind-the-scenes look at a strange moment in sports history. The Islanders still have not fully recovered from their disastrous 90’s, and only with their impending move to Brooklyn next year is there a glimmer of hope for the franchise to truly begin turning things around.
For fans of hockey, this one should definitely be high on the list of great stories from the series, if only because there aren’t that many stories about hockey.
Hockey is back. So that means it’s time for me to make some wild guesses as to how the regular season will play out over the next 82 games. Maybe even make a way-too-early Stanley Cup prediction that will surely not come true, if only because I guessed it.
*denotes playoff team
1. *St. Louis Blues: Looking at that roster, it is just so deep. Their top-6 are among the best in the league, and that D is impressive. I think Elliott and Allen can get it done in net.
2. *Chicago Blackhawks: They are going to be Cup favorites again. Another incredibly deep team. No reason to think there is any drop off in them this season.
3. *Dallas Stars: Ok, I’ll bite. All offense, very little D. But that can work in the regular season.
4. *Colorado Avalanche: I don’t think the drop off will be as huge as the advanced stats say. This is still a young, fast, exciting team.
5. *Minnesota Wild: Made some good moves. Still a lot of questions in net, where not much has been done to improve themselves. They seem doomed to always be battling for a playoff spot.
6. Nashville Predators: Same old, same old. Solid D. No offense. I don’t know that James Neal makes that big a difference without Malkin on his line. There will be some good stories here, like a possible Ribeiro comeback, but that’s about it.
7. Winnipeg Jets: Still, nothing has been done to improve this team. They need to blow it up, if their GM realized that making trades was allowed. Horrible goaltending will sink the potential of the forwards and young D again.
1. *Anaheim Ducks: Deep, big, strong. A regular season beast of a team again, even with the changes in net.
2. *Los Angeles Kings: The champs will coast through the regular season again, waiting to make their move in the playoffs, as usual.
3. *San Jose Sharks: Despite the weird off-season, they are still a strong and deep team. There is absolutely enough there to be a good regular season team again.
4. Vancouver Canucks: I hated the Ryan Miller signing, but this team will bounce back a little bit after the debacle that was the last year. Still not a ton there, and I feel this team needs some massive changes to get back into the race.
5. Phoenix Coyotes: Always underestimated. Strong D and goalies will carry them, but who knows who will score goals for them?
6. Edmonton Oilers: Blah, blah, blah, youth. They will be better, especially with actual NHL goalies on their roster this year, but there is too much ground to make up to be much of a threat in this scary conference.
7. Calgary Flames: They worked their butts off last year, and probably over-achieved. They will be in the running for Connor McDavid this year.
1. *Boston Bruins: They remain the class of the East. Best goalie, best D, deepest forward crop.
2. *Tampa Bay Lightning: Another exciting team. Biggest question mark for me is in net. Is Bishop a one-year wonder?
3. *Montreal Canadiens: Mostly put them here because I don’t know who else I reasonably could. A decent team, but nothing special here, in my opinion.
4. Toronto Maple Leafs: Once they fire their terrible coach, they might be a decent team. Still, no playoffs.
5. Florida Panthers: I guess the only surprise pick so far. There is something going on here, and with a real goalie and a ton of youth, they could be pretty decent for once.
6. Detroit Red Wings: 25 years in the playoffs is a long time. The run ends this year. The forwards are either too old and frail, or too young and inexperienced.
7. Ottawa Senators: There just isn’t much to like here, except perhaps a nice bounceback year for both goalies.
8. Buffalo Sabres: I actually think they will be significantly better than last year. They are doing their rebuild right, and there is a lot to work with here, as they move forward.
1. *Pittsburgh Penguins: I’m already going to pick another playoff collapse, but with two of the best players in the world, they will probably run away with this division.
2. *New York Islanders: Yup, you read that right. The Islanders. I feel they made a ton of improvements over the summer, and are ready to get back into the dance. I feel there is some serious potential on this team, and if Halak can be semi-competent in goal, they have a real shot at being a special team.
3. *New York Rangers: They lost a lot since the Cup finalists last year, but they will still be respectable. Especially since Lundqvist is still their goalie. That alone gets them in in this messy division.
4. *Columbus Blue Jackets: Quietly a respectable team again. They work hard, and have some skill and nice building blocks. Hopefully there isn’t too much of a drop off in net, or with their won’t be named training camp holdout forward. He needs to shake off the rust, and fast.
5. *Philadelphia Flyers: I really like a lot of the talent on this team. If someone like Giroux decides to play the whole season, I could see them finishing as high as third in this division.
6. New Jersey Devils: I don’t really get this team. But they will hang around for most of the year.
7. Washington Capitals: Where have you gone, Southeasy Division? Getting Trotz as a coach was the right move, but there are far too many gaps in this roster, and you have to wonder how long they will buy into his system.
8. Carolina Hurricanes: I predict that they will win the lottery, and sadly, will get McDavid. Which is too bad, because let’s be honest. Not many people care that Carolina even has a team. One of hockey’s most forgotten about franchises. They are going to be bad, I feel. Sabres bad.
Randoms, and Playoffs:
Hart Trophy (MVP): John Tavares, Islanders. It’s time. And with a better team around him, he will shine.
Art Ross (scoring): Sidney Crosby, Penguins. Betting against this is basically betting against him being healthy, or getting injured. He is by far the best in the game.
Norris (best D): Alex Pietrangelo, Blues. Changing of the guard. The potential is there. With a little more offense, he will be in the conversation again.
Vezina (best goalie): Tuuka Raask, Bruins. Such a good team. He benefits from that. Oh, and being really good as a goalie.
Stanley Cup Final: St. Louis vs. New York Islanders. Not only do I think the Isles will make it back to the playoffs this year and win their first series since 1993, I think they will go all the way to the finals, shocking absolutely everyone. This is how wide open, and weak, I feel the East is this year. There will be at least five teams from the West that could beat the Isles in a series, but that’s what happens when geography occurs. I will pick the Blues to do it this year.
In the history of NHL hockey uniforms, few garner the absolute vitriol of fans in the same way that the fisherman logo uniforms of the New York Islanders do.
Pretty much the entire 1990’s should be washed from our collective uniforms loving minds, especially in the NHL. There were far too many failed experiments, typically with third jerseys. There were so many notable epic failures, and often the Islanders new design falls into this category, along with the LA Kings Burger King thirds, the never-used St. Louis Blues trumpet blasphemies, the Wild Wing Mighty Ducks third. There are so many bad jerseys from this time. The list goes on and on.
I don’t believe that the Isles new uniforms deserve to be lumped into this category. I will defend them. In fact, I kind of like them, and would love to get my hands on one. Secretly, I hope that they will bring them out of mothballs one of these days and wear them as their new third jerseys, or for a special throwback occasion. It will probably never happen, as fans will take to the streets in protest, but I think it would be awesome.
The Islanders are kind of cursed as being one of those teams with uniforms that are deemed to be classic. And granted, they are a nice looking set, and there are many great teams associated with those unis. Four Stanley Cups in a row is nothing to sneeze at, and fans rarely want to go away from tradition in that way. But the Islanders, always the distant second team in New York, have always been willing to rattle the cages and shake things up. They continue that tradition to this day, with their orange alts, and their currently well-hated black ones, that look like football uniforms reminiscent of the awful Atlanta Thrashers thirds.
The fisherman logo went away from the traditional NY in a circle logo that they had had since the beginning of their existence. They created a new logo, of an intimidating fisherman, holding a hockey stick, with Islanders written underneath. Granted, the man looked an awful lot like the Highliner Fish Stick man, but that is neither here nor there.
The Isles also went away from their traditional blue and orange colour palate, opting for a darker blue, some aqua marine, and a type of creamsicle orange. They continued to push, by creating the wave pattern on the uniform, which included wavy names and numbers on the back of the jersey.
People still despise this, but good luck on trying to get one, even on ebay. They have become collectors editions. If they ever do re-issue these guys, sign me up for a Tavares #91 right now.
I respect that the team was trying to do something different. They were trying to boost sales, trying to keep up with other teams and their constant uniform changes, and they were trying to break with tradition and start something new. I get it.
There was such an outcry over the fishermen unis, that it only took a year or two before they plastered their old logo on the new uniforms, and then eventually went back to their original designs. Which is too bad. With the fisherman, they had something new and unique, that still represented where they were from. Not all logos are able to be geographically representative like that.
I say bring back the fisherman, as a third jersey. Now that it has been years since its first appearance, it will be welcomed back with a kitsch value that we see with other logos, such as the old Mighty Ducks one. We hated it so much we wanted it gone, but now we kind of want it back. Sure those names and numbers on the back were a mess, but overall, this is a pretty solid uniform, and I’ll admit that the colours looked pretty good on the ice, and would now look especially good when watching them in HD.